What would publishing look like if we started from scratch?

Random House Publishing Group president Sanyu Dillon on how publishers can become more flexible without losing their editorial judgment

Why do publishing seasons still exist? Why does it take 12 months to bring a book to market? And should publishing houses continue to organize themselves around imprints, or would it make more sense to focus on different types of readers?

Published: 17.11.2026  |  Foto / Video: Instagram, Sharjah Book Authority

These were some of the questions raised by Sanyu Dillon, president of Random House Publishing Group, during a conversation with Nadia Wassef, co-founder of Egypt’s Diwan Bookstores, at the 16th Sharjah Publishers Conference. Asked how she would build a publishing company if she were starting from scratch today, Dillon offered a direct response: “I would throw out all conventional wisdom.”

Her remarks highlighted the need to reconsider practices that have shaped traditional publishing for decades, particularly as consumer behaviour changes and publishers face growing pressure to become more flexible and responsive.

Questioning established practices

For Dillon, the relationship between publishers and authors is one area where traditional arrangements could evolve. She pointed to entrepreneurial authors who want greater involvement in the commercial performance of their books, suggesting opportunities for different partnership models. The internal organisation of publishing companies could also be reconsidered, with reader profiles potentially playing a greater role alongside traditional imprint identities. 

She also questioned the lengthy timelines traditionally associated with publishing, asking why bringing a book to market should take 12 months rather than 12 weeks. These questions extend to distribution, where Dillon suggested that publishers should examine how to maintain strong retail partnerships while developing direct relationships with consumers. 

Her experience in marketing has shaped that perspective, particularly as the ways readers discover and purchase books continue to evolve. “We used to be very focused on driving distribution to retail. The retail landscape has completely transformed in the US and now we have to drive demand,” Dillon observed. 

That shift requires publishers to understand their audiences more closely and consider readers’ needs earlier in the publishing process, rather than concentrating primarily on how books will reach retailers.

The importance of taking risks

Rethinking traditional practices, however, does not mean abandoning editorial judgment or prioritising efficiency at any cost. Dillon stressed that publishers must preserve their willingness to take risks, even when commercial pressures encourage more conservative decisions.

She recalled a period when her company withdrew entirely from romance publishing after observing declining sales, going from hundreds of titles a year to none. The genre subsequently experienced a resurgence during the pandemic, but the publisher had lost its position in the category. The mistake, she explained, was interpreting changes in purchasing patterns as a decline in demand for romance itself. Readers had increasingly moved from mass-market paperbacks to ebooks and, later, trade paperbacks.

The experience reinforced the importance of distinguishing between a category in decline and a shift in how readers consume it. Financial discipline remains essential, Dillon argued, but it should not prevent publishers from investing in books they believe in.

“The best day in a book’s life is when an editor acquires it,” she remarked, highlighting the enthusiasm and conviction behind editorial decisions.

The same balance applies to organisational growth. Publishers need systems and processes to operate efficiently, but excessive standardisation can undermine the creativity on which their businesses depend.

“You can scale your way out of creativity,” Dillon cautioned, explaining that investing too heavily in rules and procedures can discourage independent thinking and limit opportunities for innovation.

Putting readers at the centre

Understanding readers is another priority, although Dillon cautioned against assuming that sophisticated research systems are the only way to achieve it. Random House Publishing Group has invested in consumer data and segmentation, but she emphasised that research should complement rather than replace editorial intuition. “The data only tells one part of the story,” she explained, adding that she regularly speaks with readers to understand their habits, motivations and ways of discovering books.

Smaller publishers and booksellers can also gather valuable information through surveys, events and direct conversations with their audiences. “It doesn’t have to be a huge, expensive segmentation project. It is literally as simple as talking to readers,” Dillon pointed out.

This approach also informs the company’s marketing strategies. With book discovery increasingly fragmented across influencers, podcasts and digital communities, Dillon argued that publishers must look beyond plot and genre to understand what readers expect from a particular book. “What job is this reader hiring this book to do?” she asked, referring to the marketing framework known as jobs to be done, which focuses on the needs and motivations behind consumer decisions.

For publishing companies, this means developing strategies around individual titles and their audiences rather than relying on formulas that worked in the past. As Dillon noted, successful campaigns have become increasingly difficult to replicate, even when publishers invest in the same channels and approaches.

That willingness to question established approaches also applies to leadership. Dillon argued that publishers must remain open to ideas from across their organisations, rather than allowing established processes to discourage new thinking. “Ideas are fragile and ideas can come from anywhere,” she said, emphasising the importance of remaining receptive to different perspectives.

Das ist eine Zwischenzeile

magnific_960x0.jpg_cpgacGd0eP

Sanyu Dillon (LinkedIn) is President of the Random House Publishing Group at Penguin Random House in the United States. She joined the company in 2004 and served as Chief Marketing Officer before assuming her current role in 2023. She also sits on the Penguin Random House U.S. Board.

What would publishing look like if we started from scratch?